What Does It Mean When She Says You Deserve Better? (SOLVED)

(This post may have afilliate links. Please see my diclosure)

If you’ve ever heard this from a girlfriend, wife, or partner, then you know how confusing it can feel. I’ve been there, and it kinda sucks.

What does it mean when she says, “You deserve better?”

When she says, “You deserve better,” it means that she is not interested in you, suffers from low self-esteem, wants reassurance, and/or doesn’t want to hurt you. She may even want to break up with you. You should interpret the phrase as a red flag and consider exiting the relationship.

That is the overall meaning, but there are at least 15 more specific meanings that you need to know.

Read: What Does It Mean When She Says, “Please Don’t Hurt Me”?

When She Says You Deserve Better (15 Meanings)

Woman against a purple background—What does it mean when she says you deserve better
Image by author via Canva—What does it mean when she says you deserve better

After a few of my former girlfriends told me I deserve better, I did some real soul searching.

Through this time of reflection, I drilled down to 15 different meanings buried inside of the phrase, “You deserve better.”

Let’s look at those 15 hidden insights.

1) She is not that into you

When your girlfriend says, “You deserve better,” it can mean she is not very interested in you.

If she were more interested in you, she may still think it but would probably not say it.

Just imagine her saying it to her dream guy, to a celebrity, or to a guy in the top 1% (6′ tall and 6 figures). Odds are, she wouldn’t because she would do everything in her power to make the relationship work.

Whenever I hear this phrase, I immediately think she is less interested in me than I am in her.

2) She struggles with self-esteem

When someone doesn’t value themselves, they don’t think they deserve good things.

She might have just experienced a really bad breakup where her ex pushed her away or treated her poorly.

If so, she will often use the following type of labels to describe herself:

  • I am too broken.
  • I am not worth it.
  • I don’t deserve anything good in my life.

If she struggles with self-esteem, she likely isn’t ready for a mature, healthy relationship. She needs time to work on herself.

If a girl ever says this, it’s a red flag that she is not the one (at least not right now).

This doesn’t mean that you can’t or shouldn’t date her, but you probably should proceed with caution. It’s going to be an issue in your relationship.

Remember, it’s not your job to convince her that she deserves you.

In my experience, the best relationships happen between two people who highly value themselves and each other.

3) Red flag of character issues

She may feel bad about her past behavior. Guilt can do a real number on our feelings of self-worth.

What could she feel bad about?

Maybe she cheated, took someone for granted, lied, or lived an alternative lifestyle that she now regrets or thinks you won’t like.

Although it’s no guarantee, it could be a red flag of deeper character issues.

I highly recommend that you ask her what she means and gently excavate anything in her past that may disrupt your current relationship.

4) Lack of motivation to change

Always remember: if she wanted to change, she would.

When she says she doesn’t deserve you, what she really may mean is that she doesn’t like you enough to become better.

She refuses to raise herself up to her expressed standard of you.

As much as it hurts to hear, you are not enough for her to want to change.

If she doesn’t value you, then she doesn’t really want to be with you.

5) She’s not brave enough to leave you

It could also mean that she wants to break up with you but isn’t yet brave enough to leave.

In this case, the phrase reveals her underlying fear.

She may not want to be alone or she may want to set up a backup plan for when she eventually exits the relationship.

6) She wants you to be the bad guy

If she is not able to muster enough courage to break up with you, she may say “you deserve better” so that you break up with her.

In other words, she wants you to be the “bad guy” by ending the relationship.

It allows her to get what she wants (the break-up) without having to do the hard work herself.

7) Discrepancy between reality and fantasy

The phrase reveals that the relationship may be very different than what you envisioned.

You probably like her more than she likes you. This is a classic story of pursuing someone in a one-sided relationship. For example, is it always you reaching out to her? Does she ever call or text first?

Once this becomes apparent, it can be a huge shock to your system.

“You deserve better” indicates that you view her and the relationship through a completely different lens she does.

You may overlook flaws in the relationship and unintentionally idealize her or your connection.

Watch this great video where a relationship expert answers a client’s email about this very issue:

YouTube video by Susan Winter—What does it mean when she says you deserve better?

8) She wants reassurance

Then again, she may simply want your reassurance.

Yes, she may deal with a less-than-perfect self-image, but who doesn’t?

Sometimes, we just need to know that our partners value us and don’t judge us for our past or our flaws.

Let her know that you care about her, think highly of her, and see her as a beautiful person worthy of love.

9) She’s testing you to see if you will stay with her

Women sometimes test men to see if they will rise to the occasion or crumble under pressure.

It’s quite possible your girlfriend could be testing you.

When tested, stay grounded and centered. Don’t get thrown off your game. Coach Corey Wayne, a relationship expert, suggest that you ask yourself, “What would James Bond do?”

The bottomline is to remain cool, calm, and collected.

10) She doesn’t think you two are compatible

Your girlfriend or partner may say this phrase if she doesn’t see the two of you as a great fit.

Women sometimes say things so that they don’t hurt a guy’s feelings.

Instead of directly telling you that she doesn’t see a future with you, she may “let you down easy” by saying “you deserve better.”

11) She can never repay you

Another possibility is that she is very appreciative of everything you have done for her.

Her deep gratitude may come with the knowledge that she can never repay you.

So, she may feel uncomfortable with how much you’ve given compared to what she has offered in the relationship.

While this can seem like a good thing, I suggest you really look at the give-and-take balance. There is almost always some imbalance, but a massive difference should get your attention.

If you always play the giver and not the receiver, you may want to exit this lopsided relationship.

12) She found someone better

She could have found someone better and needs to get out of her relationship with you.

This is more likely to happen before the two of you go exclusive, but it can happen anytime. Pre-exclusive dating is fragile.

Things can change very quickly, so try not to take it too personally.

13) She wants attention

Sometimes “You deserve better” is a play for attention.

Everyone craves attention, especially from the people we care about the most.

This request for attention can feel uncomfortable because of the self-worth undertones, but that’s not always a break up worthy problem.

If it’s a rare request for attention, I wouldn’t worry about it.

However, if she repeatedly downplays her personal value to get your attention, I would lovingly talk to her.

14) She knows she will probably hurt you

It’s likely that she thinks she is going to hurt you in some way.

Here are the most common culprits:

  • She will use you
  • She will not give as much as she takes
  • She will cheat on you
  • She will treat you casually
  • She will leave you

Usually, she bases her prediction on her own past behavior.

If you look into her past, you might find a long list of other guys who she has hurt. She’s giving you a fair warning.

If I were you, I’d believe her.

15) The universe is telling you to move on

You can also view her saying, “You deserve better,” as a clear sign from the universe (or Higher Power) that you should end the relationship.

Most of the time, a healthy person with no major unresolved issues will not say this phrase.

So, in this way, it’s a bright red flag.

It’s a sign that you should break up and move on. If she is not ready to be with you, then you need to let her go so that she can focus on yourself.

You can’t save her, fix her, or make her better.

She is the only one who can give herself true happiness, value, and peace.

How To Respond When She Says You Deserve Better

When she says, “You deserve better,” what do you do? How do you respond?

The first thing I think you should do is believe her.

People often accept the love they think they deserve. If she doesn’t think she deserves you, she is probably right.

You probably do deserve a woman who values herself, finds fulfillment in herself, accepts herself, and believes she is worthy of someone great.

Secondly, I suggest you respond gently to her.

What you say depends on what you want to do. If you want to stay, say that to her. If you want to leave, let her know.

She’s being honest with you, so be honest with her.

If you want to leave (which is what I recommend):

“Thank you. I know that is probably hard to say. I really appreciate your honesty, but it’s obvious that we are not on the same page about this relationship. We will end up resenting each other, and I don’t want that.

As much as it hurts, I think it’s best if we take a break. I hope that you come to realize that you deserve someone wonderful. I care enough about you to give you the time and space to figure that out.”

If you want to stay (and I know that sounds like the romantic thing to do):

“I think we are both worthy of love. I want you, and I hope you want me. Please take some time to think about it and let me know whether or not you wish to continue our relationship. If I don’t hear from you, I’ll assume that you want to move on and I’ll respect your decision.”

Here is a short video about what to do when a woman says that you deserve better:

YouTube video by Apollonia PontiWhat does it mean when she says you deserve better?

What Does It Mean When A Single Woman Says You Deserve Better?

If a single girl tells you that you deserve better, then she might be flirting with you.

Depending on your situation, you can respond with, “Thank you,” or even flirt back with her. Of course, if you are in a committed relationship, then I suggest that you avoid flirting and simply appreciate her comment.

Another scenario is if this single woman is a good friend of yours.

In that case, she probably is just looking out for you and your best interests.

Final Thoughts: What Does It Mean When She Says You Deserve Better?

When you don’t know what your girlfriend (or anyone else) means, ask them to clarify. You don’t need to be a mind reader.

You can simply say, “What do you mean?”

Ask whatever follow-up questions you need to fully understand the context, motivation, and deeper meanings.

Related articles:

Sources

Pubmed.gov

Oxford Academic